Home COACHES DAY WESTERN FORCE REDS VS CANES WK 1 WALLABIES OVERVIEW 1 OBSERVATIONS,  LAWS WEEK 2 S14 WK 2 WALLABIES WEEK 3 S14 ROUND 3 S14 WK 3 WALLABIES WEEK 5 S14 WEEK 6 S14 WEEK 7 S14 WEEK 8 S14 REDS TOUR WEEK 9 S14 WEEK 10 S14 ANDREW JOHNS WEEK 11 S14 WEEK 12 S14 WEEK 13 S14 WEEK 14 S14 RIAN CHERRY ORIGIN LEAGUE TITLES LEAGUE TITLES 2 U18 LEAGUE 3 LEAGUE 4 THE WORLD CUP THE WORLD CUP 1 SACRIFICE RAUDONIKIS

Written Friday 09/02/2007

JUST SOME MORE GENERAL STUFF

You go through some funny stuff in life,  and perhaps we should write it all down.  Perched high in the Suncorp Stands on Saturday night,  courtesy of the guy I work for who provides tickets on a rotational basis for his staff (the good thing is,  there is only two or three that are rugby fans,  most like the league and have to jostle for tickets,  so the few of us that spread ourselves over the four available Platinum tickets for the rugby are quite lucky. 

I wish to go talk about a few things that happened during my time at Suncorp on Saturday,  03/02/2007. You can't go past my suited counterpart cleaning his teeth in the toilets,  already mentioned.

  1. The commercialization of rugby is quite annoying.  While I realize it has been necessary to keep the good or better athletes in the game,  the hullabaloo that accompanies it drives me insane.  First you have the annoying guy on the microphone conducting any number of SMS competitions,  interspersed with the reasonably untalented (as singers) QR Queensland Reds performing the "team song" with plenty of gusto and volume.  You can’t even make out what Quade Cooper is saying as he performs the rap section.  It was always good to watch a couple of curtain raisers.

  2. Then,  during the game,  and when the QR Queensland Reds are on attack,  the war drums and the screaming banshee at thick glass breaking levels ( I think it is supposed to be a whistling train but seriously sounds like someone experiencing some outrageous discomfort and amplified to head splitting levels.  Personally don’t like it.

  3. Flags,  they should be banned.  They are annoying when you are trying to watch the footy,  big ones,  waving about in front of you,  I can see why they banned the Mexican wave.

  4. People that have no idea but want to get involved in conversations that have nothing to do with them,  and carry on like pork chops when they are wrong.  This happened twice on Saturday night with two folks in front of us,  obviously experts on the game,  but not knowing how wrong they are.

    1. The first incident in the second half,  the Hurricanes kicked off and the ball didn’t travel 10 metres,  one of the Qld props has elected to play on,  and the ball has been knocked on at the ensuing breakdown,  scrum,  Highlanders 5 metres in Qld territory.  A person in my group asked me what happened  and I was explaining to that person that if the kick off doesn’t go 10 metres and the receiving side decides to play on,  then it is indeed play on.  If the kicking side decides to play on,  or they just stand around looking at it on the ground,  it comes back to a scrum on the halfway,  receiving side’s feed.  That is the Law I’m afraid but the two guys in front of me wanted to have a bit of a chop,  saying that it had to come back to the half way for a scrum,  Qld feed and that Kaplan was wrong.  Well,  Kaplan was right,  they were wrong,  however,  I stayed out of the argument,  that time,  but they excelled themselves a little later.

    2. A Hurricane attacking just inside the Qld half,  maybe around the 40 metre mark,  drops the ball and there is a little toe through by the Hurricanes,  and Shifcoske picked up on about the Qld 22 metre line,  he jinked left,  circled right and passed inside to Peter Hynes  who stepped and jinked to the touchline,  and then into a hole forwards,  looked like being tackled into touch,  passed inside and forwards to Rodney Blake,  but still before the position of the original knock forward from the Hurricanes.  Kaplan blew a scrum,  uncontested of course by this stage,  Hurricanes feed.  Again I was asked by a person in my group to explain the ruling.  For mine,  there are two Laws that come into play here,  the one that says,  THE REFEREE IS THE SOLE JUDGE OF FACT AND LAW,  and that THE REFEREE SHALL APPLY ALL THE LAWS OF THE GAME FAIRLY AT ALL TIME (note it is cleverly written and does not say that he will be correct at all times,  just fair) and ADVANTAGE IS TO BE TACTICAL OR TERRITORIAL.  I certainly agreed with Kaplan that play had gone on long enough,  and the QR Queensland Reds had got themselves into a better position until the forward pass for advantage to have accrued,  a tactical advantage.  The people in front however wanted to join the conversation and be quite belligerent,  some head shaking and some you haven’t got a clue stuff.  I told them that next time I would bring a law book,  to their head shakes.  Bit of a turn off at times the old Live Sport with so many experts wanting to help me out.  You will find that if the offence being "advantaged" is a penalty offence,  then the advantage will play on for longer and the official will be looking for a more significant advantage than for a scrum offence.

    3. The third one was interesting too.  The Reds put a kick through,  that bounced near I think Ma’a Nonu.  He tried to touch it but did not,  and the ball bounced rather severely back towards the Reds side where it was picked up by another Hurricane,  a long way in front of Nonu (who had tried to but not touched the ball) and he played on,  as did Kaplan,  to the raucous cries of off side.  Again Kaplan was correct,  we were still in general play,  and the only thing that would have put the second Hurricane off side was Nonu touching it,  otherwise,  he was free to and did play on.

 

The Man at the Top of the Mountain Didn't Fall There!

Copyright 15manrugby.com,  2007.